Many moons ago, a man worried about carrying a snake across the water. He worried the snake would bite him and he would die. The snake tried to assure the man — if he bit the man, the snake would drown, and they would both die. The man, fooled, picked the snake up and proceeded to swim. The snake bit the man, and the man began to die, but not before asking the snake why — why kill them both. The snake reminded the man that he was a snake, and that the man knew that when he picked the snake up.
Many moons ago, a man I will refer to as ***** appeared at my door and asked me to teach him. The man had a history of questionable conduct but I thought, perhaps, I could help make a difference, and so I opened my teachings to him.
Shortly thereafter, at a seminar I did not attend, ***** got up and introduced himself as a “Gulao Wing Chun student under Robert Chu”. I was on the Wing Chun Mailing List (WCML) at the time, and several other WCML members who were at the seminar contacted me an let me know about *****’s claims. And while I hadn’t accepted ***** as a formal or direct student (which, culturally, has more requirements than simply a lesson), he had flown out to train with me, I had tried to help him improve his Wing Chun, and he did express a great interest in continuing to train with me, so I responded simply, “if he wants to call himself my student, that’s fine.”
And continue with me he did. Since he had trained a long time but, unfortunately, didn’t have a lot of direct access to a teacher (he travelled to train), I felt it best to concentrate on his basics and especially his structure. For me, all Wing Chun Kuen “styles” are merely different teacher’s expressions of the art, and if you have a solid core structure, you can easily use (for who would want merely to collect?) any “style” and, eventually, come too appreciate them for the many perspectives and insights they allow.
Keep reading »