Secrets!
by Andrew Nerlich, October 21st, 2007
Secrets are a big deal in martial arts circles (”Duhhh!”, you say).
All too often, “secrets” are used as magnets for the easily duped, or to make a practitioner or “master” appear more interesting, knowledgable or mysterious than they actually are. An earlier column of mine (”False Prophet”) details my unfortunate dealings with one such practitioner.
But reconsidering, I hope I can convince you that there is value in a controlled flow of information from teacher to student.
For example, the Brazilian Jiu Jitsu Black Belt who regularly gives seminars at our kwoon, John Will, is adamant that if he teaches a particular technique to a group, that he will never teach a counter to that technique in the same lesson, and probably not until some time later. To teach the counter too early would discourage the students from trying the technique in freestyle grappling and thus prevent them from learning to apply it effectively - a corollary of which would be that they never learn to counter really well either, since none of their classmates bothered to learn the technique properly! Keep reading »

